i have a 2TB external hard drive, it was working perfect with my windows laptop, until i switched to MAC it was also working (no issues), when i switched back to windows it wont work (USB Device not recognized), however when i attached it to mac again it worked . but not with windows anymore.
the problem now that, i sold my mac and just using windows but not able to access my data on HDD.
If you had formatted your hard drive on your Mac you will have a problem on any Windows-based system since the Mac-optimized HFS+ file system is incompatible with Windows.
You could try a program that allows for Windows to read HFS+ partitions though.