WD Blue SSD 500GB unable to boot

After formatting with Disk Management and installing windows onto the SSD I am unable to boot directly from the SSD. However, when starting the PC a screen appears which allows me to choose a drive with the old version of windows on my HDD and the new version of windows on my SSD. When removing the HDD I am unable to boot from the SSD at all, instead it takes me to the BIOS screen. Reordering the boot order does not help either.