1TB My Book Studio Edition-Won't turn on. Feel drive spinning but no light on

I have two 1TB My Book Studio Editions that are hooked up to a Mac Pro through two Firewire 800 ports.  The problem I’m experiencing is a couple weeks ago one of them stopped working.  The Mac Pro won’t recognize it and the light won’t come on.  I could feel the hard drive spinning inside though.  I questioned if it had something to do with the switch and if I needed to turn it on to get the light to work.

I have two of these drives so I went to the 2nd drive and pressed the switch a few seconds and it turned off.  Then I pressed it a few more seconds expecting it to turn on but it won’t so now both drives aren’t working.

What would cause it to spin when plugged in but not have the light come on or have the computer recognize it?  Is there a trick with the switch that is causing me not to be able to turn on the second drive?

I am using these drives as Time Machine drives for two laptops that we have connected through the WiFi network to the Mac Pro. Originally I had two WD 750GB drives.  Both of them became defective during warranty and WD replaced both with these 1TB drives.  Unfortunately these are now out of warranty.  Over time I’ve found them to be unreliable at times.  Often all I would have to do is either unplug it and plug it in again, unplug the Firewire 800 and plug it in again, etc. and it would work. 

On a side note, I know these hard drives and most others have two FW800 ports for daisy chaining.  I’ve always connected both drives directly via two cables to a couple FW800 ports on my Mac Pro but I know they can be used to daisy chain it so I just use one FW800 port on the Mac Pro.  If I do this in the future, would it cause a decrease in performance or would the drives run just as fast?

Thank you for your help.

Try using a different cable… I’ve seen problems with the drive coming on when connected to a bad data cable.

Connecting both drives through daisy chain will not affect the performance…

We need to get the drives working first though

Check if the drivea are showing on Disk Utility

I am experiencing the same thing. One thing I have noticed is that when is “dead” the bar graph under the name in the display disappears. If it is there, it most likely is working. In looking at a post on apple, and other posts, it looks like the “my book” is just piece of junk. Not reliable at all Mike