I don’t think you can (the Setup settings specify digital passthrough for either one or the other)
You could use “splitters” if both devices have the same input
eg. if both (DAC & AVR) have SPDIF (Toslink) then use a splitter (use Passthrough for Optical) and use the HDMI for Video Only
or if both have HDMI (For Video and Audio) then use a spiltter (use Passthrough for HDMI)