My Book Live: Not recommended at all

This is the best NAS I have ever owned!!! Just to show you how people can differ…

I use SCP/SFTP all the time remotely, never had any issues. I do not use FTP because it is unsecure.

I can load/unload data all the time without issues, locally or remote

I am using a static IP since day 1

Public is, as its name implies, Public. Easy to delete/rename and/or change writes access. Heck, you can even create any folder with any permissions you want very easily, all in the manual.

Ans yes, if you compare MBL to a USB drive, you will have lots of issues. It would be like comparing apples to orages.

Good luck with your next choice!