Should i get the RED or the Green 3TB drive?

As I said, I’m a burned child !
I have 17TB (7 x 2TB, 1 x 3TB) on two computers in use, not counted the Boot-Disks which are smaller Raids.

When I had problems with the 2TB in past, I ALWAYS was able to get my data back and save them to another Disk, even the HDD died after that.
Now I have a problem with the (green one) 3TB Drive ( it will be the first and last).
No working tools can be found and I’m jumping from one problem to another, starting with BIOS through Controller Drivers up to Operating System and ending with a fatal “important Win7-Update”…

My best wishes, hope you’ll find the best decision for yourself